Skip to content

Editor for novelists · Edinburgh

Novels edited in pencil, one manuscript at a time.

Assessments, edits and proofreads for novelists, from a book-lined study in Marchmont. I take on eight to ten manuscripts a year; the next opening is in March.

Alasdair at his desk in a book-lined study
The studyMarchmont, Edinburgh

Reading

  • Manuscript assessment

    from£650

    I read the whole novel twice and write you a long letter on structure, pace and character.

    Two readings · a 12-page letter · an hour's call

  • Opening chapters

    from£180

    The first three chapters and the synopsis, read closely before you send them out.

    Three chapters · synopsis · written notes

Editing

  • Structural edit

    from£1,600

    The whole shape of the book: what to move, what to cut and what's missing.

    Notes on the manuscript · a chapter map · two calls

  • Line edit

    from£1,400

    Every sentence, in pencil first, for rhythm, clarity and voice.

    A marked-up manuscript · a style sheet

  • Copyedit

    from£900

    Consistency, grammar and the facts, checked before it goes to an agent.

    Tracked changes · a style sheet

Before you send it

  • Final proofread

    from£500

    One last careful read of the finished text, for the errors everyone else missed.

    One full read · marked corrections

  • Submission letter

    from£90

    Your letter to agents and its synopsis, tightened to a page each.

    Letter · synopsis · one round of notes

Nothing to pay until I've read your opening chapters. I reply within a week.

Shop

A checklist, and my drawings

The checklist I give every novelist before they send me a draft, and my drawings from the study on tees, mugs and prints.

Close portrait of Alasdair in his charcoal cardigan

About

Hello, I'm Alasdair

I edited fiction at two publishers for twenty years before going freelance, and I've now worked on about three hundred novels: debuts, second books, crime series and one very long trilogy. I work alone, from a book-lined study in Marchmont.

I read every manuscript twice before I write a word, and I edit in pencil on paper first. I'm slow on purpose. You'll get a long letter, a marked-up manuscript and an hour on the phone, and I'll tell you plainly what I think the book needs.